I took the tray outside and covered it with a few coats of blue spray paint. I then took a profile picture of my daughter and printed it out.
I originally just planned on tracing her picture with a black sharpie and coloring it in, but my brand new sharpies would not write over the paint. It was time for plan B!
I ended up tracing the cut out onto gold scrapbook paper and gluing it onto black and white polka dot paper.
(the paper looks wrinkled, but I promise I smoothed it out)
I applied a thin coat of Mod Podge then poly to make it waterproof.
My daughter loves the tray and it's a great place for her to put her water at night.